Showing posts with label art. Show all posts
Showing posts with label art. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 17, 2012

d&g on art

From What Is Philosophy:

"Art preserves, and it is the only thing in the world that is preserved. It preserves and is preserved in itself, although actually it lasts no longer than its support and materials--stone, canvas, chemical color, and so on. [...] If art preserves it does not do so like industry, by adding a substance to make the thing last. The thing became independent of its "model" from the start, but also independent of other possible personae who are themselves artist-things, personae of painting breathing this air of painting." (164)

Saturday, January 21, 2012

making, meaning, knowing

After reading text after text about institutional racism and sexism, I turned to my brilliant sister for some reading suggestions. Something uplifting. Her answer? Ellen Dissanayake. With only a chapter remaining of Art & Intimacy, I am positively giddy. Like so many other authors/books that have changed my life, I cannot wait to talk about, write about, and assimilate Dissanayake's ideas. For now, the following:

"The challenge...was, in all acts of life, to transform the contaminated and impure into the culturally infused and human. This--no more and no less--was the meaning of life."1

In an era permeated (perhaps even defined) by toxicity, Dissanayake's observation of the Yekuana culture becomes all the more pertinent and (for me at least) poignant. Sullied by capitalism, industrialism, and a kind of mutated Enlightenment individualism, we are bereft. We scramble for truth and hold fast to illusion. Could it be that the paucity of transformational making is to blame? In a society where the simple acquisition of material goods is valorized and the complexity and nuance of empirical knowing virtually absent, fulfillment and meaning are indeed diaphanous and distant.

As I read Dissanayake, I couldn't help but think of the unique and damning problems that come with the performing arts. What happens when "making" does not result in an object? For example, in the life of a musician--where that which is made is temporal, transient, and without artifact--the issue of "hands-on" knowing produces an unpredictable (and yes, often toxic) series of  psychological ripples. We make yet produce no object, we strive for the Truth/Notion/Idea through a means that requires isolation and elitism (in contrast to Dissanayake's assertion that art and relationships go hand in hand). We toil so that we might contribute to that dangerous dialectic of the intentional and the ineffable. 


1.Dissanayake, Ellen. 2000. Art and intimacy: how the arts began. Seattle, Wa: University of Washington Press. 78

Saturday, October 8, 2011

octavio paz on music

"The paradox of music, a temporal art like poetry, lies in the fact that music's characteristic manner of taking place is recurrence. The kinship between music and poetry is based on their both being temporal arts, arts of succession: time. In each of the two recurrence, the phrase that returns and is repeated, constitutes an essential element; the motifs intertwine and disentwine so as to interwtine once again; they are a path that ceaselessly returns to its point of departure only to depart once more and return again. The difference between the two lies in the code: the musical scale and the word. Poetry is made up of rhythmic phrases (verses) that are not only units of sound but words, clusters of meanings. The code of music--the scale--is abstract: units of sound empty of meaning. Finally, music is architecture made of time. But invisible and impalpable architecture: crystallisation of the instant in forms that we do not see or touch and that, being pure time, elapse."

Paz, Octavio. Essays on Mexican Art. New York: Harcourt Brace, 1993. (6-7)

Monday, August 15, 2011

agnes martin = hero


Agnes Martin, Milk River, 1963. Oil on canvas, 72 × 72 in. (182.9 × 182.9 cm). Whitney Museum of American Art, New York; purchase with funds from the Larry Aldrich Foundation Fund 64.10

When I think of art, I think of beauty. Beauty is the mystery of life. It is not in the eye, it is in the mind. In our minds there is an awareness of perfection.

Tuesday, July 26, 2011

back from vacation

Oh, hello there CMM blog. Didn't see you there.

(figure lovely vacation: 1920s carousel)

Having just returned from a lovely vacation, I am slowly but surely acclimating to the reality of my life: starting a new job (and concert series!), moving to a new city and apartment--a vita nova on every account. Certainly, there are a good many things to write about. Plagued by an unexpected and ostensibly insurmountable writer's block, I will--rather than writing something cohesive--list some things to read and see. Enjoy.

Zizek: an interview and an excerpt; this was one of the best shows I have ever seen; a video installation about which I hope to write someday when I have regained my ability to string a few words together; Renaissance choral music in Minneapolis here and here; and for your weekly McCarthyism, go here.

Tuesday, June 21, 2011

the phenomenology of religious spaces (part one of many)

Are you ready? I've been ruminating on this since my moment of spiritual clarity in Portugal. Following is a few questions I hope to turn into, with more reading, a few cogent abstracts.

1. How does ornament operate as a coercive force in art? What are the implications of ornament in various contexts? Specifically, what is the phenomenology of ornament? How does one quantify the visual experience of ornament? What occurs within the body when completely overwhelmed by visual stimuli and how does this contribute to the formation of a malleable mental state? Furthermore, if one accepts the premise that ornament overwhelms the body thus priming the same body for suggestion, could one then discuss the phenomenology of ornament with rhetoric similar to that which surrounds the femme fatale?

2. If ornament is indeed a coercive mechanism, does the Catholic Reformation establishment knowingly utilize it? How does this deployment of ornament complement the theatricality of Catholic Reformation painting? Do we accept sixteenth century religious art as an intentional manipulation of reality, with more duplicitous, sinister overtones than other artistic contexts?

Caravaggio, The Crucifixion of St. Peter (1600-1601)

3. How do religious aural environments contribute to the coercive force of their visual complements? If we accept that sound initiates within the body physiological reactions similar to those that occur in response to violence and trauma, how then does the otherworldly quietude create a tranquility that fosters a malleable mental state? Is it the silence of religious spaces that makes us feel safe, and thus receptive to spiritual ideas?

Isn't new research wonderful?

Tuesday, May 3, 2011

the postmortem continued

Today, I had the realization--both terrifying and exciting--that I am leaving for Portugal in two weeks. Two weeks. Truly, this is not much time. I've continued to ruminate on Friday's presentation and in doing so, several more avenues have come to light. The information, the research, I think, is good. However, the presentation needs work. I need to frame it as something like I am no longer a performer. I began to ask myself questions about the body, music, and subjugation and found that I could no longer continue. For the next twenty minutes I wish to share with you my research in hopes that it will provoke questions in  your own musical practice, scholarship, or pedagogical method. Furthermore--and I don't mind saying it again--this is not a twenty minute paper.

So, again for my own piece of mind, I'll offer an alternative introduction to get the taste of Friday's nonsensical bumbling out of my mouth. Eccolo:

In the next twenty minutes, I will not give an answer, nor will I offer a definitive conclusion or method about or for the performance of eighteenth-century music in the twenty first century. I wish to illuminate the sinster tradition in which both musical text and performance are implicated. I wish to pose a series of questions regarding musical, cultural, and scientific performance. I wish to discover and discuss the body as an "object and target of power" in both the eighteenth and twenty-first century.

Albinus, Bernhard Siegfried. Tabulae sceleti et musculorum corporis humani. (1749)

In a world wherein every word, object, and sign is loaded with (plural) discourse, perhaps the only way to free ourselves and to appropriate and indeed reclaim these signs is to fully understand their genesis and manifestation. We must empower and free ourselves through cognizance; through knowing.

A little better than Friday, I think. The goal in the next two weeks is to really push the anatomy theater/musical performance angle. The more I look at these images; the more I think about the practice of anatomy in the eighteenth century (and prior), I cannot help but connect the dissected, sexualized, controlled, ordered, sacrificed body of the cadaver to the sexualized, controlled, ordered, sacrificed body of the eighteenth century performer.

Friday, April 22, 2011

when nothing is beautiful anymore (except edith wharton)

There exists an apocryphal tale: the day Charles Ives stopped composing was the day he announced, "nothing sounds good anymore."

Although dubious in its origins and accuracy, this anecdote has remained with me since first I heard it. The disparity and hopelessness that, ostensibly, motivates such a statement is staggering. Ives's supposed utterance is indeed spurious, however the idea that one can become so saturated with sameness that the dichotomy of good and bad no longer exists articulates so perfectly one facet of the post-modern aesthetic. Or could it be that Ives, so inundated by post-war angst and early twentieth century sonic detritus, could no longer conceive a cogent expression? Who is to say, really. What is more thought provoking is 1) the lack of contrast that results from the saturation of imagery (this part of Greenberg's kitsch, by the way) and 2) the effect that an increase--and yes, an inundation--of stimuli has on the artistic psyche. Maybe I'm being a little dramatic, but in the wake of re-reading The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction (and you know, all that time I spent ruminating on Baudrillard) I couldn't help but think of Ives as a victim of twentieth century saturation/stimulation/commodity fetishization/etc.

This time around, Benjamin really got to me. Like most of us, I've had the "we're going to hell" conversation many times: nothing is beautiful, presented with every possibility, we are left in a turbid ether disengaged, disembodied, and cognitively disemboweled. You know, that conversation. Revisiting Benjamin, what seemed a knee-jerk fear-inspired attitude now appeared prophetic; an apparition marked by ineffable veracity.  We are disembodied by technology, daily--what was once reserved for the film star has proliferated into the banal and mundane. Divorced from carnal experience, we exist in virtual multiplicity. Benjamin identified and predicted this crisis in the 30s, and here we are: nothing sounds good anymore.

On a more positive note, I picked up a copy of The Age of Innocence yesterday (a purchase inspired by Ta-Nehisi Coates) and, I would be lying if the word-smithing above was not inspired by Wharton's command of her craft. Behold:


Then the house had been boldly planned with a ball-room, so that, instead of squeezing through a narrow passage to get to it (as at the Chiverses') one marched solemnly down a vista of enfiladed drawing-rooms (the sea-green, the crimson and the bouton d'or)...


And my favorite part:


seeing from afar the many-candled lustres reflected in the polished parquetry, and beyond that the depths of a conservatory where camellias and tree-ferns arched their costly foliage over seats of black and gold bamboo.


Okay, one more:


The immense accretion of flesh which had descended on her in middle life like a flood of lava on a doomed city had changed her from a plump active little woman with a neatly-turned foot and ankle into something as vast and august as a natural phenomenon. She had accepted this submergence as philosophically as all her other trials, and now, in extreme old age, was rewarded by presenting to her mirror and almost unwrinkled expanse of firm pink and white flesh, in the centre of which the traces of a small face survived as if awaiting excavation. A flight of smooth double chins led down to the dizzy depths of a still-snowy bosom veiled in snowy muslins that were held in place by a miniature portrait of the lat Mr. Mingott; and around and below, wave after wave of black silk surged away over the edges of a capacious armchair, with two tiny white hands poised like gulls on the surface of the billows.


That, my friends, is virtuosity. "...traces of a small face survived as if awaiting excavation." Gen-ius. Last one, I promise:


She always, indeed, struck Newland Archer as having been rather gruesomely preserved in the airless atmosphere of a perfectly irreproachable existence, as bodies caught in glaciers keep for years a rosy life-in-death.


I'm going to go read now. Sigh.

Thursday, April 21, 2011

bits and bobs

I'm presently working on many (perhaps too many) projects--and of course, moving, starting a new life, getting ready for baby's first paper session--but during my breaks, I've been catching up on my leisure reading. Some things of interest:

From the Chronicle, a nicely articulated piece about the Bible; Ta-Nehisi Coates *hearts* Edith Wharton and it completely inspired me to read The Age of Innocence (or The Age of Awesome); More Coates (beautiful remembrance of the departed Marable, articulates the best sort of protégé/mentor bond); on undergraduate business degrees (I much appreciated the shout out to philosophy majors!); no more jokes about my practice of meditation (here); Being on Exodus (I'm absolutely inspired to pick up the good book this week--looking forward to investigating posed questions and the plurality of interpretations); From a friend, this is funny. Anything else? Spending time here, with him, revisiting this, and thinking of it in conjunction with this.

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

post-human, post-apocalyptic proliferation

This article came across my Google Reader recently via Arts and Letters. Chernobyl has fascinated me since first I heard about its burgeoning ecological renascence; Shukman describes the "irradiated eden" with vivid imagery. Paradoxically vivified by post-nuclear, post-human, and indeed post-apocalypic circumstance, Chernobyl's primeval ecology has asserted itself. Shukman's account of a utopic forest, drenched in radiation and host to a potential plethora of genetic mutations and micro-evolutions, provides a "real" example of Baudrillard's Telecomputer Man. The technological, the biological, and the toxic have fused in a post-nuclear horror.

As I read, I couldn't help but think of a visual analogue to the micro-evolutionary processes occurring in the Exclusion Zone. There is something about Tetsumi Kudo's so-called post-humanism that screams idyllic mutation and mutilation; an eerie and ultimately unsettling coalescence of the human, the natural and the mechanized.

Tetsumi Kudo: Love (L’Amour) (1964). Chairs, cotton, plastic, polyester, electrical diagrams, vinyl tubing, hair, painted wood box, and audiotape, 39 3/8 x 47 x 23 5/8 in.

Tetsumi Kudo: Pollution—Cultivation—New Ecology (Pollution—cultivation—nouvelle écologie) (1971-1972). wood, artificial flowers, artificial soil, cotton, plastic, polyester, adhesive, wire, transistors, snail shell, hair, mirror, paint 18-3/4 x 23-3/4 x 14-1/8 inches

Thursday, February 24, 2011

wax, hegel, and the intrinsic disparity of existence

To punctuate my nearly month long silence, I thought I'd offer some notes from my most recent research projects. To be honest, the next few months will likely be filled with notes related to "baby's first conference appearance." Who wants to read about wax models, Stamitz, Foucault, epistemology and scientific illustration? That's right. You do.

So where to begin? Last night I found myself pouring over Sawday's The Body Emblazoned. Naturally, I went into the anatomy section for Galen and came out with Galen plus six other texts, Sawday among them. Although not necessarily his main point, Sawday's recurring references to that oft referenced duality of mind/body (a post yet to be written, Sawday brings up some very interesting points about temporality/phenomenology, leading me to consider the relationships between tonality, desire, and expectation) led me to revisit Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit and the disparity of being and actuality. When I first read the text weeks ago, I had the following to say about it:

The entire preface articulates a desire to reconcile disparate epistemologies. On the one hand we get some pretty intense critiques of eighteenth century categorization/compartmentalization/naming and the curiosity cabinet mentality (collect the extremes as a way of understanding the totality of the physical world - pg. 8 para 15). Also at one point, he eschews the "mundane" (5, para 8) and for me, this reference screamed "the body." Maybe that is oversimplifying it, but it just seemed like another dig at the eighteenth century. These critiques are then complemented by his advocacy of unified knowing, without superficial categories (and especially the act of naming) the infinite is implied in the ineffable. You also get this conflict of how to deal with process in the acquisition of knowledge, something that I read as another manifestation of this 18th/19th century conflict. Hegel espouses a kind of self-reflexivity necessary for successful scientific inquiry (and that this is a good thing), an assertion that to me, expresses this 18th/19th century conflict/synthesis. This awareness/refelction is a big deal for him (clearly), but I couldn't help but think of it in terms of the nineteenth century preoccupation with the mind (maybe an oversimplification).

Returning to it now in the context of the eighteenth century wax model, I have a few things to add to something previously dismissed as fin-de-siecle angst. [1]

In my mind, wax presents us with an ideal symbol of Hegel's thoughts on process, essence, and "being." Hegel returns again and again to an advocacy of the cyclical, the anti-teleological (this being the so oft referenced "dialectic"). To me wax would, ostensibly, represent a physical analogue to Hegelian philosophy. Its embodiment of process--its malleability, genesis, and connection to the natural world--in congress with its function and reception in eighteenth century Italy and beyond, articulates the crisis with which Hegel seems to be concerning himself. At once the medium evokes the warmth of human flesh while being bound to discourses surrounding death. Indeed, this is the paradox of anatomical study from Vesalius to Cowper to Hunter, Bidloo, etc etc.

To me, Hegel's negative--the disparity of being and actuality--offers a philosophical framework within which the anatomical wax model can be understood. Presented in a medium capable of evoking the nuances of human flesh while simultaneously trapped by its culturally constructed limitations, wax occupies--in its intrinsic duality--the space of that which simultaneously is and is not. The medium so accurately depicts its subject but it is this accuracy in and of itself that results in tropes of duplicity (and yes, femininity) that haunt practices of wax anatomists and sculptors.

Or something. Phenomenology is something I still have some troubles with, but my instincts tell me that in the case of wax artists in the eighteenth century, there is indeed a connection.

[1] Speaking of the fin-de-siecle, or rather that particular fin-de-siecle, there is a great article by one of my very favorite musicologists on the subject. If you have access, check it out here.

Friday, October 29, 2010

papa schoenberg's ca-razy cohort

Some time ago--when I was young, stupid, and arrogant--I had the opportunity to take a seminar on fin-de-siecle Vienna. At the time the readings were difficult, the concepts fresh and the names relatively unknown. Although at present, my thoughts are mostly tied up with eighteenth century anatomical wax models (yes, you heard me), I recently had occasion to return to the world of Loos, Schoenberg, Wieninger and Bahr. Below are a few excerpts from my most recent draft. I really encourage you to think about this, this, and this in the context outlined below.

An Overview: Characterized by an excessive anxiety, Vienna at the fin-de-siecle provided a locale ripe for artistic and cultural turmoil. In the political sphere, the immediate government opposed the values of the bourgeois and intelligentsia: Karl Lueger and his anti-Semitic Christian Socialist coterie offered an ideological foil for Vienna’s cosmopolitan citizens. Such political disparity likely contributed to “secessionist” tendencies among artists and intellectuals. Indeed, a desperate advocacy of cultural re-nascence, famously articulated by literary critic and dramatist Hermann Bahr in his 1890 essay The Modern, permeated the Viennese firmament. Bahr’s battle-cry further foregrounds the intensely spiritual, often delusional (even delirious), narratives ascribed to artistic creation at the fin-de-siecle.

Weininger's Sex and Character: Overt in its misogyny, pristine in its logic, Sex and Character gives a particularly eloquent voice to the deeply troubled fin-de-siecle man. When considering the text one must negotiate one’s own disgust: looking beyond the urge to apply myriad derogatory “isms” affords the reader opportunities to experience—through Weininger—the fin-de-siecle masculine psyche in all its anxieties, fears, and indeed, perversions.

Loos, Wagner & Ornament: Adolf Loos’ biography, written oeuvre and architectural output suggest an ideological dissonance. Seeking to resurrect and, if I may be so bold, purify architecture, Loos famously declared that ornamentation was indeed a crime. In his essay, Ornament and Crime, Loos evangelizes for an austere style liberated from filigree, devoted to formal unity. While performing this identity of modernist apostle, Loos simultaneously advocated an almost excessive use of craft and ornament within the home. Such a negotiation of modernist aesthetic propriety illuminates not only Loos’ inextricable links to nineteenth century thought, but also his insidious application of Victorian feminine containment to architecture and interior decorating.

In general, there exists an obsession with ornament in fin-de-siecle art and theory. Furthermore, Loos equation of applied art with degeneracy operates within and validates the gendered confines of genius.

Schoenberg: If one accepts the condition that Schoenberg’s atonal and dodecaphonic music asserts the composer’s masculinity, one can also postulate the existence of what Foucault would call “aims and objectives” intrinsic to Schoenberg’s textual and musical oeuvre. Given what we now know regarding the composer’s cultural context, I would argue that not only does Schoenberg’s modern style express fin-de-siecle aesthetic ideology but also operates within the context of artistic and cultural misogyny.

As an end note, I'd like to briefly evangelize for this book. Go. Read it.

Monday, August 30, 2010

qualunque cosa monday

Museum culture in WSJ; For the penultimate paragraph's insight into touch (plus I like Miro); Objectivist silliness; "The humanities have been gutted by four decades of pretentious postmodernist theory and insular identity politics." Read the rest here; Pirates!; Nature, "the void," and air: architecture in Venezia

Monday, August 23, 2010

qualunque cosa monday

Matisse at MOMA, but more interestingly--how do we look at art? Picasso and the Ballet Russes; Jessica Duchen on performance practice partially in response to this piece from Stephen Hough; Pretty picture from APOD; I'm not a Twitter-er, but this is kind of amazing (via Alex Ross); My primary area of interest from SEP; And speaking of the Enlightenment; This is incredible, and not just because I have a soft spot for antiquity; This is not a joke! More from APOD (I just like the pictures); Intrigue! Academic malfeasance @ Havard; YouTube find; I do like Dumas...but that is not really the point--the art market is mean.

Monday, August 16, 2010

qualunque cosa monday

General miscellany that I don't particularly feel like writing into prose. Today is sort of out of date since I have been catching up on my Google Reader. Consider this the first installment of a weekly feature. As an FYI, qualunque cosa roughly translates as "whatever thing"

My friend and yours: Boethius; Something from Alex Ross that made me laugh out loud; If only my theory class was like this; APOD catch-up; Interesting if a little superficial, but I love me some Charles Rosen; Dear Frank Gehry, will you be my friend? Those wacky mathematicians; Insight into the horrific artworks of the Brothers Chapman, though I'd still suggest their work is more sensationalism than substance; A "Joke" from David Oistrakh; And while we're on the subject of YouTube; Childhood memories of paging through my parents' art books, among them an Alice Neel exhibition catalog; More from SEP; More from APOD; I *heart* design; Thank you. I hate it too; Yikes.

Friday, July 30, 2010

guy debord's "specatular marxism"

A short one from the "drafts" file. Below is an excerpt from some of my class notes on the Situationist International:

Guy Debord, et al--Situationist International rejects materialism;
problem of objects in post 1945 art--society
Spectacular Marxism

Am I the only one who finds the phrase "Spectacular Marxism" rib-ticklingly hilarious?

In reality, it ought to read "Society of the Spectacle; Marxism" as in this.

All jokes aside, the SI is pretty great. I'm completely pressed for time, so here is a link to SI online.

Wednesday, June 23, 2010

yoko, oh no!

The great thing about having your own music festival is that you can entertain ideas like programming Ono's Cut Piece. For our immediate future, this is completely not feasible. Let us all take a moment to imagine what it would be like if I performed Cut Piece--wherein the audience cuts off the performer's clothing until she/he is naked (or nearly so)--at First Lutheran Church of New Richmond. Right. It basically goes without saying that this would not be an option. However, I like the idea of programming some of Ono's works (how very conceptual of me!). Until recently, I'd been largely (though admittedly unjustifiably) an Ono naysayer, but taking an open and unbiased look at Cut Piece and the rest of her Fluxus-era oeuvre has completely turned me around. There are a few common themes running through much of her work that fit neatly with our mission statement, the most pertinent being the concept of the gift and the idea of audience participation. There is quite a bit more to say about Cut Piece and the rest of Ono's continually expanding oeuvre, for now I'll just include a video of the 1965 Carnegie Hall performance...


Notice the disturbing pace at which the piece progresses; the carelessness of the audience. There is something deeply unsettling about the performer/participant dynamic: something violent, disrespectful, and crass. Indeed, much more to say...

Thursday, June 17, 2010

jottings, chiefly on visual + musical egalitarianism*

So I'm working on a short little flurry of a paper about what I'm calling "visual egalitarianism" in Jackson Pollock and his Abstract Expressionist colleagues. Thinking critically about the lack of a focal point or any sort of representation** in their work brings me back to this idea of equality and absolutism expressed in artistic forms. Considering the former, a few examples come to mind: Schoenberg and the Second Viennese School, Kandinsky, the AbEx'ists, Boulez, and Cage. With regards to the latter, I'm thinking of the First Viennese School, and the general "academic" style of Western Europe (anyone from Michelangelo to Titian to David, even Gerome).

Indeed, before we get to Kandinsky and the Second Viennese School [of Rock] and their descendants (Boulez/Pollock et al), we have to first look at their predecessors: the First Viennese School [of Rock]. The musical forms and aesthetic of the eighteenth century really offer a fantastic aural analogue to the socio-political milieu of the era. I'm specifically thinking about the disparity between the aristocracy/ruling class and everyone else. Essentially, musical hierarchies in the form of tonality (ie the tonic, dominant, and leading tone are the "important" scale degrees. An oversimplification, but you get the idea) mirror social structures (class). I'd really like to know a whole lot more about the French Revolution, but for now I'll just say that it is completely compelling the way that strict musical forms and harmonic structure begin to erode around the beginning of the nineteenth century, following various political upheavals (the French Revolution being just one example). Beethoven's Eroica is actually a great example of this in that the sonata form of the first movement is, well, jumbled. By reorganizing a then-familiar form, the composer challenges our expectations, thus subtly implying social change. Maybe. This is all pretty speculative.

So with this in mind, Schoenberg's Pan-Tonality (that is what he said) takes on a new social meaning. When he literally refers to it as an emancipation--how can we not read a kind of "liberation narrative" into the work? Considering also what we know about fin-de-siecle Vienna, Schoenberg's musical freedom-fight gains more complexity. At once, the composer is a member of the political minority (Christian socialist Lueger is in power) while also participating in a (sometimes violent) patriarchy. That is not to say that he was a misogynist (as far as I know, he wasn't), only to note the often complex relationship of minority to majority(ies). In a very real sense, the emancipation represents not only a break from the musical past, but also implies a kind of Utopian ideal--not surprising given Schoenberg's own biography and what I can imagine would be a hell of a time living in Vienna around 1900.

With regards to the visual arts, I'd like to discuss Kandinsky and the AbEx'ists. Taking the example of Kandinsky, we can notice a break down of visual hierarchy, something like Composition IV (1911) is tottering on the brink of non-representational art.
Figure non-representational: Kandinsky's Composition IV
Although that is a sort of "well, duh" analysis, the aforesaid connection between abstraction and equality is what makes this sort of thing compelling. Recently, I was speaking with one of my mum's friends (a visual artist) about Schoenberg and this idea of pantonality as a representation of equality; being an awfully sharp tac, she brought up Kandinsky's work--for her, the musical analogue in that when art is non-representational, all shapes, colors and lines are equal. This conversation still fresh in my mind, I began to mull over the notion of representation as being inherently unequal with regards to the AbEx'ists.

These guys were, in my mind, both ideological and stylistic descendants of Kandinsky. Similarities abound, the most obvious being the non-representational style and a sort of spiritual relationship between artist, canvas, and material (the material being much more important for the AbEx'ists). However, more intriguing is the American public's reaction to Pollock and his pals. Upheld as arbiters of a quintessential American art, their works and personae were used as a cultural weapon in the cold war: they were celebrated as visual symbols of democracy. Certainly, you can discuss the movement of the avant-garde from Paris to New York; the American adoration of the "new," but from my perspective the notion of visual egalitarianism is the most "American" aspect of their work.
Figure visual egalitarianism: Pollock's Autumn Rhythm

*that is a little Aristotle jokey-joke(!) Yay Poetics!
**I'm thinking here about formal hierarchy: there is an inherent value judgment in notions of foreground versus background. Indeed, one might argue that a line that implicates contour is more important (valuable) than one that participates in say, a cross hatch. The main idea being that in representational art, one line can have more meaning than another.

Wednesday, June 2, 2010

papa schoenberg

Like a true champ, I left all of my Schoenberg-related texts at home: Schorske's Fin-de-Siecle Vienna, Alex Ross' The Rest is Noise, Janik's Wittengenstein's Vienna, Tuchman's Proud Tower, even the big-bad Morgan Twentieth Century Music. I'll do my best. Though for anyone curious about the cultural history surrounding Schoenberg and his circle, I would highly recommend the Schorske. If you want something broader, Tuchman is great as well. But I digress.


There are (clearly) quite a few things to say about "Papa" Schoenberg. Since I'm featuring works very early (Brettl Lieder, 1901) and very late (Phantasy 1949) in his oeuvre, in the program notes I will discuss his formative influences and their subsequent culmination in his twelve-tone compositions.

Before discussing the music, there are quite a few cultural influences (even though I truly hate that word) that need to be addressed. One cannot deny that Vienna around 1900 was a hot-bed of clashing socio-political, artistic, and philosophical mores (if memory serves, Schorske describes these things as the "forces of movement"). Let's take a brief inventory of these aforesaid conflicts, shall we? Karl Lueger and the Christian Socialists (think pre-Nazis) governs a largely Jewish bourgeois. Visual artists trained in the ways of the academie attempt to find a fitting aesthetic to rebel against it. The burgeoning mid-nineteenth century feminist movement continues to gain steam thus causing reactions both subtle and violent. In conjunction with these conflicts, you also have the culmination of nineteenth century idealism, especially in art. This creates an interesting synthesis in that the artists of the era were perpetually trying to start anew (things like Ver Sacrum and Barr's The Modern), yet their attitudes were inextricably linked to nineteenth century attitudes and ideas. The most clear examples are in visual art and music.

In the visual arts, the early nineteenth century notions of artistic genius become so over-blown that you get things like this (alluding to him), this (quoting this), and this. More than merely a vessel for divine inspiration, the artist has become divine. Furthermore, there is the (overt) intimation of martyrdom. It is no coincidence that the term "avant garde" comes into use in the second half of the nineteenth century.

With respect to music, the relationship between past and then-present is more subtle, less violent, even (to use an analogy popular in nineteenth century criticism) biological: Schoenberg's twelve tone music is the "grown-up" version of Bach--or at least that was how he saw it. Indeed, the composer viewed himself as a member of a noble lineage. But, in keeping with the attitudes of his artistic comrades-in-arms Schoenberg certainly viewed himself as an arbiter of the "new." Musically, this sort of attitude can be seen in the combination of a decidedly novel harmonic/melodic idiom (twelve tone/pantonal) with archaic rhythmic structures (the waltz, the baroque dance etc). Below is a great youtube find of Menuhin and Gould discussing this combination. I think Menuhin has a nice analogy to describe the relationship of underlying form and outward aesthetic.

Pretty good, eh? I really do think Menuhin's analogy is apt: like in the Shakespeare example, the underlying forms in Schoenberg are at times extremely subtle and you really need to have a knowledge of, shall we say, musical iconography. The music gains completely new meaning when you can not only identify a waltz, but recognize that in the context of twelve tone music it signifies the Vienna of days gone by. Furthermore, in post-WWI Europe the mutilated waltz could be interpreted as a symbol of a scarred, disfigured countryside strewn with corpses, punctured by warfare (images of Under Fire are still lingering in my mind, apologies).

Menuhin also points out that when all tones are equal (the musical reflection of the ever-growing egalitarian spirit of the twentieth century, but that is a separate entry...), all you have are tone-colors and silence, and I would add, rhythm. To make the music interesting, the performer must exploit the variety and range of the violin in addition to truly understanding the tradition from which Schoenberg emerged.

There is indeed, much more to say. The issue of dodecaphonic music as an expression of egalitarianism is really quite fascinating. It become even more captivating when you contrast it with say, the musical language of Mozart. Where Schoenberg celebrates musical equality, Mozart (whether intentionally or not) enables rigid class structure with rigid tonal hierarchies. Indeed, much, much more to say.

Monday, May 24, 2010

a fool for foucault

I just started Discipline & Punish. Heaven help me.

When I say "just" I truly mean it--I've only read the first few pages (what I could get through during last week's La Valse; the orchestra sounded so good, it was hard to concentrate on my reading...)--but the accounts of punishment in terms of eighteenth century spectacle and nineteenth century compartmentalization made me think about certain aesthetic concerns of the former.

I'm thinking specifically about the body--by including an eighteenth century account of torture (written in, by the way, classically matter-of-fact style), Foucault illustrates the era's interest in man as a physical being (as opposed to a spiritual one as in the Medieval era, or mental as in the nineteenth century). Because much of my recent reading and thoughts have revolved around the epistemological shifts occurring between the conversion of Constantine and the Scientific Revolution, I cannot help but view torture through this particular lens. What is truly fascinating is the way the practice of torture interacts and reflects upon then-contemporary art, philosophy and science.

Lately I have been thinking about the eighteenth century as a sort of confluence of empiricism, scholasticism, classical thought (specifically Aristotle's Poetics, among others...), and the last gasps of the Reformation and the Scientific Revolution's luminous afterglow. You end up with social change and Enlightenment philosophy, but we already knew that. To me, the changes in how individuals viewed themselves is what is truly captivating. Because of the aforementioned cultural milieu, philosophes and the so-called "great unwashed" alike experience a re-nascence (if you'll pardon the pun): a new egalitarianism is born out of the coalescence and subsequent synthesis of medieval and early modern ideals. Subtle thought it may be, these things work together to empower physical man, always returning to the sensational experience of living.

So what then, do you get in art and culture? Low dance forms in "high" art (the gigue, for example), the prevalence of the pastoral (as we will see in Tyler Wottrich's performance of Mozart's Piano Concerto no. 17), things like (the other) Fragonard, Madame Tussaud, La Specola, David's rendering, and of course, revolution.

I bring all of this up because I think it is so important to understand the cultural turmoil from which the first Viennese school (Mozart, Haydn, Beethoven) emerged. Although on the surface their music may seem "pleasing" (a description favored by the eighteenth century critic), it is rife with the tension of duality: empirical thought versus scholasticism, feeling versus rationality, the grotesque versus the ideal. The next time you listen to Figaro, just remember that a few blocks from the opera house, there was a good chance of being able to witness torture in all its unfettered, disquieting brutality.